Maybe I'm just a spaz but I have put big tears in the Drylocks, also in the Patagonia R3 gloves. I liked those a lot but mittens just keep me warmer, and they don't hurt when it comes to paddling. I did just notice that Patagonia makes boots, too. And I'd love an R2 fullsuit (I was just trying to write "fullsuit" but I mistakenly typed "fullshit" ha ). I rolled up the Xcels too and that helped, but trying to do anything with mittens on is a lesson in patience, which I don't have, apparently, judging by the tears.
The Rip Curl mittens just looked more solid somehow. Whatever. I'll just get 'em and see.
Thanks for all the input.