spending a lot of time chasing barrels in jersey has changed my mind about which boards are best. Too much length doesn't seem the best for those waves. the drops are quick and steep, and the barrels are small. Even if the waves seem big at first the barrels are often pretty tight.
For longer period open ocean big stuff I think you can benefit from a longer board. or if the barrels are wide, but for around here, smaller, but still with volume, seems better.
This thread has some info:
http://www.nynjsurf.com/forum/buy-and-sell-the-surfboard-exchange-on-nynjsurfcom/wtb-6364-rusty-slayer-type-board-t32987.0.html and the board I went with:
http://www.nynjsurf.com/forum/shapers-shack-surfboard-repair-restoration-and-shaping-tips/slayer-type-board-t33330.0.htmlkeep in mind this is coming from a very mediocre surfer. I just want to get in, under the lip and in the tube.